Read the original article here.

---

Single-Board Computers (SBCs): Integrating the Core Components

In the journey to understand "The Lost Art of Building a Computer from Scratch," one of the most illuminating paths is exploring the concept of the Single-Board Computer (SBC). Unlike the modular, multi-board systems common in desktop PCs, the SBC philosophy is about integrating all, or most, essential computer functions onto a single circuit board. This approach offers unique insights into how components like the central processing unit (CPU), memory, and input/output (I/O) interfaces are brought together to form a functional machine.

What is a Single-Board Computer?

A Single-Board Computer (SBC) is a complete computer system built entirely on a single printed circuit board (PCB). It includes the core components necessary for a functional computer, such as one or more microprocessors, memory (like RAM and storage), and various input/output (I/O) ports and controllers.

Think of a standard desktop computer. It typically has a large motherboard, separate graphics cards, sound cards, network cards, storage drives connected via cables, and RAM modules plugged into slots. An SBC aims to put as many of these functions as possible directly onto that single board.

This integration simplifies the system architecture, reducing the need for connectors, cables, and multiple circuit boards. This simplicity can lead to advantages in size, cost, power consumption, and reliability, making SBCs ideal for specific applications where a compact, integrated solution is preferred over a highly customizable, multi-board system.

SBCs are commonly designed for specific purposes:

• Educational Systems: Providing an accessible platform for learning programming, electronics, and computer hardware basics (e.g., Raspberry Pi).
• Embedded Systems: Acting as the control unit within other devices, such as industrial machinery, appliances, vehicles, or medical equipment.
• Development Platforms: Serving as a base for engineers and hobbyists to prototype and build new electronic products or projects.
• Specialized Applications: Used in areas like data acquisition, process control, media streaming, or compact servers (e.g., blade servers).

While many home and portable computers (like laptops) essentially function as single-board systems internally, the term "SBC" is often specifically applied to boards designed for the educational, hobbyist, embedded, or industrial markets, which may have different form factors, I/O mixes, and design philosophies than typical consumer motherboards.

Components of an SBC

Understanding an SBC is like looking at the fundamental building blocks of a computer condensed onto one board. The key components you'll typically find include:

1. Microprocessor(s): The "brain" of the computer, responsible for executing instructions. SBCs use a wide variety of processors, from simple 8-bit microcontrollers in early designs to powerful multi-core 64-bit processors in modern systems, often integrated into a System on a Chip (SoC).
2. Memory:
   • RAM (Random Access Memory): Provides temporary storage for data and program instructions that the CPU is actively using. Early SBCs might have used simple static RAM (SRAM), while modern ones use dynamic RAM (DRAM), often in the form of integrated chips or modules (though less common on deeply embedded designs).
   • Storage: Where the operating system, applications, and data are stored persistently. This can be built-in flash memory (like eMMC), an SD card slot, or interfaces for connecting external storage like SSDs or hard drives (SATA, NVMe).
3. Input/Output (I/O): The means by which the computer interacts with the outside world. This is a crucial part of an SBC's design, often tailored to its intended application. I/O can include:
   • Digital/Analog I/O: Pins (often called GPIO - General Purpose Input/Output) that can be programmed to read simple on/off signals or control external devices.
   • Communication Ports: Serial (UART, SPI, I2C), Parallel, USB, Ethernet, Wi-Fi, Bluetooth.
   • Display Interfaces: HDMI, VGA, Composite Video.
   • Audio Interfaces: Input/output jacks, digital audio outputs.
   • Expansion Headers: Connectors that allow attaching add-on boards or peripherals, though often more limited or application-specific than the expansion slots on a desktop motherboard.

The selection and arrangement of these components on the single board determine the SBC's capabilities, size, power requirements, and cost, reflecting the trade-offs inherent in computer design.

A Look Back: The History of SBCs

The history of single-board computers is closely tied to the increasing ability to integrate more components onto a single silicon chip and, consequently, onto a single circuit board.

• The Dawn of SBCs (1970s): As microprocessors became available, engineers and hobbyists explored how to build functional computers. The "dyna-micro," based on the Intel 8080 processor and published in Radio-Electronics magazine in 1976, is considered one of the first true SBCs. This led to the production of the MMD-1 (Mini Micro Designer 1) by E&L Instruments, intended for training and prototyping microcontrollers. These early SBCs were fundamental learning tools, allowing users to interact directly with the processor and memory, often through simple keypads and LED displays, embodying the "computer from scratch" ethos. Other notable early examples included the KIM-1 (based on the MOS Technology 6502), which was popular with hobbyists and educators. These boards often came bare, requiring users to understand and potentially build their own enclosures and peripherals.

• Home Computers and Early Integration (1980s): Many popular home computers of the 1980s, such as the Acorn Electron, BBC Micro, Commodore 64, and Apple II (though the Apple II had expansion slots, the core CPU/memory/I/O were on the main board), were essentially designed around a single main board. While they often had connectors for peripherals, the fundamental computer resided on one PCB, making them relatively compact and cost-effective for the time. Some designs even included solder points for user-installed upgrades, further blurring the lines between a finished product and a system open to modification.

• The Rise of Modularity (1990s): The dominance of the IBM PC architecture and the standardization of buses like the PCI bus led to a shift towards highly modular systems. Desktop PCs adopted large motherboards primarily housing the CPU, main memory slots, and standard bus connectors. Functions like graphics, sound, networking, and complex I/O were relegated to separate "daughterboards" or expansion cards plugged into these slots. This model offered tremendous flexibility and upgradeability, fostering a large market for interchangeable components. SBCs, in their original integrated form, saw a decrease in market share outside of niche industrial or embedded applications.

A Motherboard is the main printed circuit board found in general-purpose computers (like desktops and laptops). It holds the central processing unit (CPU), main memory, and other essential components, and provides connectors (slots and sockets) for attaching other peripheral cards and devices (like graphics cards, storage drives, etc.).

A Daughterboard is a smaller circuit board that plugs into a connector on a main board (like a motherboard or another daughterboard) to add functionality or expand connectivity.

• Integration Returns (2000s): Advances in semiconductor manufacturing allowed for greater integration. New chipsets could combine the functions of multiple older chips or daughterboards onto a single chip. Standardized interfaces like USB reduced the need for a wide variety of legacy ports on the main board. PC motherboards began re-integrating many functions like audio, networking, and even basic graphics (integrated GPU) directly onto the main board, reducing the reliance on expansion cards for basic functionality.

A Chipset is a group of integrated circuits (chips) on a motherboard that manage data flow between the processor, memory, and peripheral devices. They are crucial for determining the features and capabilities of a computer system.

• The Modern SBC Boom (2010s - Present): The explosion of mobile devices (smartphones, tablets) and the Internet of Things (IoT) drove massive investment in highly integrated chips, specifically Systems on a Chip (SoCs).

A System on a Chip (SoC) is an integrated circuit that integrates most or all components of a computer or other electronic system onto a single chip. This typically includes a CPU, memory interfaces, graphical processing units (GPU), wireless connectivity (Wi-Fi, Bluetooth), and various input/output interfaces.

SoCs made it possible to put the core logic of a powerful computer onto a single, small, and power-efficient chip. This directly fueled the resurgence of SBCs, making them smaller, cheaper, and more capable than ever. Platforms like the Raspberry Pi, launched in 2012, capitalized on this, offering a powerful, low-cost SBC based on a Broadcom SoC. Originally aimed at promoting computer science education, the Raspberry Pi's flexibility and features, including programmable GPIO pins, made it incredibly popular with hobbyists for projects ranging from home automation and media centers to robotics and custom electronics.

This era saw a proliferation of similar SBCs (BeagleBoard, Orange Pi, Banana Pi, etc.), catering to different needs in performance, I/O, and price. Modern industrial and embedded systems increasingly rely on powerful, specialized SBCs, often built around SoCs tailored for specific tasks like edge computing or machine learning.

While integration offers significant advantages, the modern SBC's reliance on complex SoCs also presents challenges, particularly concerning repairability and access to low-level functions, a stark contrast to the more accessible, component-level interaction possible with early SBCs.

Applications of Single-Board Computers

The integrated nature of SBCs makes them uniquely suited for applications where size, power efficiency, cost, and reliability are critical.

• Embedded Systems: This is perhaps the most common application. SBCs are hidden inside countless devices we interact with daily.

  • Industrial Automation: Controlling machinery, monitoring processes, managing assembly lines.
  • Medical Devices: Powering equipment like diagnostic machines or monitoring systems.
  • Automotive Systems: Managing infotainment, engine control, or driver-assistance features.
  • Consumer Electronics: Smart TVs, routers, smart home devices, gaming consoles.
  • Kiosks and Digital Signage: Providing the computing power for interactive displays or information terminals.
  • Aerospace and Defense: Used in satellites, drones, and control systems where space and weight are limited, and reliability under harsh conditions is paramount. Their reduced component and connector count contributes to higher reliability compared to multi-board systems.

• Educational and Hobbyist Projects: Platforms like the Raspberry Pi and Arduino (which is technically a single-board microcontroller, a related but simpler concept) have revolutionized how people learn about computing, programming, and electronics. They provide an affordable, versatile platform for experimentation, building prototypes, and creating custom gadgets. The presence of accessible GPIO pins allows direct interaction with physical components, bridging the gap between software and hardware.

GPIO (General Purpose Input/Output) pins are digital pins on a circuit board (like an SBC or microcontroller) that are not assigned a specific function by default. Their behavior (whether they are inputs or outputs, and what signal level they should have) can be controlled programmatically, allowing the computer to interact directly with external electronic components.

• Specialized Computing:
  • Media Centers: Compact, low-power SBCs are perfect for streaming audio and video.
  • Home Automation Hubs: Controlling lights, thermostats, and other smart devices.
  • Retro Gaming Emulation: Running software that mimics older game consoles.
  • Network Attached Storage (NAS): Creating personal file servers.
  • Edge Computing: Performing data processing closer to the source (e.g., analyzing sensor data locally before sending it to the cloud).

In these applications, the benefits of a single, integrated board are clear:

• Reduced Cost: Fewer components, fewer connectors, simpler assembly.
• Smaller Size: All essential parts on one board allow for very compact devices.
• Lower Power Consumption: Often designed for efficiency, especially those based on mobile SoCs.
• Increased Reliability: Fewer connectors mean fewer points of failure.
• Simpler Design: Easier to integrate into larger systems or products.

While consumer desktop PCs benefit from the modularity and upgradeability of motherboards with expansion slots, SBCs shine where a fixed, integrated, and often smaller or more rugged solution is required.

Types, Standards, and Form Factors

While the core concept of an SBC is a computer on a single board, they come in various types and follow different standards, largely dictated by their intended application and market.

• Consumer/Hobbyist SBCs: These are typically standalone boards with a fixed set of features, designed for ease of use and versatility. Examples include the Raspberry Pi, BeagleBoard, and the various 'Pi' clones (Orange Pi, Banana Pi, NanoPi). They often feature standard consumer I/O (USB, Ethernet, HDMI, Wi-Fi/Bluetooth) and accessible headers like GPIO pins. They are usually powered via a simple DC jack or USB connector.

• Industrial and Embedded SBCs: This market segment has specific requirements for ruggedness, reliability, extended temperature ranges, and long-term availability. These SBCs may conform to established industrial standards or use proprietary designs.

  • No Slot Designs: Many embedded SBCs are designed to be integrated directly into a specific piece of equipment. They provide a fixed mix of I/O (often more industrial-focused like digital inputs, analog outputs, serial ports) with no provisions for add-in cards. They might include on-board bootable flash memory, eliminating the need for a hard drive. These are common in machine control, gaming machines, and kiosks.
  • Slot-Based (Backplane) Designs: Some industrial SBCs are designed to plug into a backplane.

  A Backplane is a circuit board with connectors (slots) that allow multiple plug-in boards (like SBCs or I/O cards) to communicate with each other using a shared bus (e.g., CompactPCI, VMEbus). Unlike a motherboard which contains the CPU and main logic, a passive backplane primarily provides power and connections for the bus signals between the inserted boards. An active backplane may include some control logic or bus arbitration circuitry.

  In this model, the SBC plugged into the backplane acts as the main processor and might include some basic I/O. The backplane provides the framework and additional slots where various specialized I/O cards (for data acquisition, motion control, vision systems, etc.) can be added. This offers some modularity while still benefiting from the integrated SBC processor. Examples of standards using backplanes include: * CompactPCI: A ruggedized version of the PCI bus for industrial applications. * PXI (PCI eXtensions for Instrumentation): Built on CompactPCI, designed for test and measurement systems. * VMEbus: An older, established standard for industrial and embedded systems. * PICMG (PCI Industrial Computer Manufacturers Group): Develops standards for industrial PCs, including backplane architectures.

  • Stacking Designs: Another approach to modularity without a traditional backplane uses stacking connectors. Boards are stacked one on top of the other, with connectors passing bus signals and power between them.

  PC/104 is a standard for embedded computers that defines both a form factor (about 3.6 x 3.8 inches) and a bus structure using stacking connectors. This allows processor boards, I/O boards, and other modules to be stacked together like building blocks.

  Examples of stacking standards derived from PC/104 include PC/104-Plus (adding PCI bus), PCI-104 (PCI only), EPIC, and EBX, offering different sizes and bus options for embedded control systems.

• Computer-on-Module (CoM): A variation where the core computing components (CPU, memory, basic I/O controllers) are put onto a single, often smaller, board designed specifically to plug into a larger "carrier board" or "baseboard."

  A Computer-on-Module (CoM) is a type of single-board computer, often in a standardized form factor, that is designed to be plugged into a carrier board. The CoM contains the core processing logic, while the carrier board breaks out the signals from the CoM's high-density connector to standard external interfaces (like USB ports, Ethernet jacks, display connectors, etc.) and provides application-specific circuitry.

  The CoM holds the complex, processor-centric part, while the carrier board provides the application-specific connectors and potentially additional circuitry. This allows developers to choose a CoM with the desired processing power and then design a relatively simple, custom carrier board tailored to their project's exact I/O needs, reducing development time and cost for specialized embedded systems. Standards include Qseven, COM Express, and SMARC. While a CoM itself is an SBC, it's typically not used as a standalone computer without a carrier board.

Common Form Factors

While SBCs can be proprietary sizes, many adhere to specific form factors to ensure compatibility or fit within established enclosures. The Wikipedia article lists several, highlighting the diversity:

• Industrial/Backplane Focused: AdvancedTCA, CompactPCI, Multibus, PICMG, PXI, VMEbus, VPX, VXI
• Stacking Embedded: PC/104, Embedded Compact Extended (ECX), EPIC, EBX
• Small Consumer/Embedded: Mini-ITX, Pico-ITX (these are also used for small motherboards, but highlight the trend towards miniaturization), 96Boards, Qseven (CoM form factor)

Understanding these types and form factors reveals how the fundamental concept of an SBC is adapted to meet the varied demands of different markets, from hobbyist projects to critical industrial infrastructure.

The Trade-offs: Integration vs. Extensibility and Repairability

The integrated nature of SBCs offers significant advantages, but it also involves trade-offs, particularly relevant in the context of "building a computer from scratch" or understanding system architecture:

• Extensibility: Compared to a desktop motherboard with multiple standard expansion slots (like PCIe), many SBCs offer limited or no general-purpose expansion. While some have specialized headers or stacking connectors, they lack the broad compatibility of standard PC slots. This means you often buy an SBC with a fixed set of capabilities, and adding significant new functionality (like a high-end graphics card or a complex multi-channel audio interface) might be impossible or require a completely different SBC model.
• Repairability: Because components are highly integrated, especially on SoCs, if one part of the system fails (e.g., the network controller or a USB port integrated into the SoC), the entire board or even the entire SoC might need to be replaced. This contrasts with modular systems where a faulty expansion card or even a RAM module or CPU socket failure might only require replacing that specific component on the motherboard. Modern SBCs, particularly those based on complex, proprietary SoCs, can be very difficult to repair at a component level. This concern is driving discussions around the "right-to-repair" and the potential for more modular designs in the future.
• Component Access: While early SBCs allowed relatively direct interaction with core components (like setting switches to load data into memory or controlling I/O via simple hardware), modern SBCs, with their complex SoCs running sophisticated operating systems, abstract away much of this low-level interaction. Understanding the "from scratch" process might be easier on a simpler SBC design or a microcontroller, where the path from instruction to hardware action is more transparent.

Despite these trade-offs, the modern SBC's power, affordability, and compact size have made computing more accessible and enabled innovation in countless areas, proving the enduring value of the single-board design philosophy.

Conclusion

Single-Board Computers represent a fundamental approach to computer design: integrating the essential components onto a single platform. From early educational tools demonstrating basic microprocessor principles to the complex, powerful SoCs powering modern embedded systems and hobbyist platforms, SBCs showcase the evolution of computer integration.

For anyone interested in "The Lost Art of Building a Computer from Scratch," studying SBCs provides valuable insights into:

• Component Integration: How the CPU, memory, and I/O are connected and interact on a physical board.
• System Architecture: Understanding the trade-offs between integrated, modular, and stacking designs.
• Application-Specific Design: How the choice of components and form factor is tailored to the intended use case.
• Evolution of Technology: Witnessing how semiconductor advances have enabled increasingly complex systems on smaller boards.

While building a multi-component desktop might teach about interface standards and component compatibility, engaging with an SBC, especially one with accessible features like GPIO, allows direct interaction with the core computing elements and their relationship to the physical world, offering a unique perspective on how computers are truly built from the ground up.